Tuesday, December 17, 2013
Majors Follow SFLOI Precedent by Havelock Hews
The major league baseball rules committee recently came to the same conclusion that Softball For The Love Of It had. It is going to stop home plate collisions. Or try to. The committee is now conjuring what set of rules and regulations will be employed.
Judging from our experience, it will not be without controversy. Despite our rule against collisions (the runner is out if he collides with the catcher) there has been a running "dialogue" between the more adventurous runners in the league and the catchers. Our rule has worked to the extent that we have eliminated full-body contact and the worst of the injuries. Still, there is a physical battle between the hard-sliding runner and the catcher. The runners (think Alex Rivera) claim that the catchers (think Havelock Hewes) must give an open pathway to home plate and, if there is no pathway, the runner has no choice but to push the catcher out of the way with a hard slide. Having been the catcher on many occasions, I know that in order to make an effective tag the catcher must hold the ball in front of home plate, the same way an infielder does in front of a base. If the throw beats the runner, the runner is pretty much out. This is not how the runners see it. The runners believe that the catcher needs to stand to the side of the base and swing his arm, pendulum-like across where he hopes the runner will be. The result of the two interpretations has been, in my case, several bruised shins and one trip into orbit. The orbit occurred a couple of years ago when Alex's sliding foot kicked my stationary foot so hard that my body spiraled 360 degrees and I landed, on my feet, right where I had been.
It will be interesting to see what the major leagues come up with.
Judging from our experience, it will not be without controversy. Despite our rule against collisions (the runner is out if he collides with the catcher) there has been a running "dialogue" between the more adventurous runners in the league and the catchers. Our rule has worked to the extent that we have eliminated full-body contact and the worst of the injuries. Still, there is a physical battle between the hard-sliding runner and the catcher. The runners (think Alex Rivera) claim that the catchers (think Havelock Hewes) must give an open pathway to home plate and, if there is no pathway, the runner has no choice but to push the catcher out of the way with a hard slide. Having been the catcher on many occasions, I know that in order to make an effective tag the catcher must hold the ball in front of home plate, the same way an infielder does in front of a base. If the throw beats the runner, the runner is pretty much out. This is not how the runners see it. The runners believe that the catcher needs to stand to the side of the base and swing his arm, pendulum-like across where he hopes the runner will be. The result of the two interpretations has been, in my case, several bruised shins and one trip into orbit. The orbit occurred a couple of years ago when Alex's sliding foot kicked my stationary foot so hard that my body spiraled 360 degrees and I landed, on my feet, right where I had been.
It will be interesting to see what the major leagues come up with.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
majors follow hewes??
yeah...and i also heard MLB wants hewes to be the next commissioner too
jeffy
majors follow hewes??
yeah...and i also heard MLB wants hewes to be the next commissioner too
jeffy
I've done my share of catching in the past and what you say its something you have to relize when your catching you don't have to block the plate as I do my plays I stand in front of plate and I either swing my arms or I wait for him. Your saying its ok to block and the runner has to go around the catcher and I say your wrong but also its not easy when it comes to bang bang plays to think this or that .
I block the plate, but always a step in front so that the runner *can* avoid me, but has to move/swerve (i.e. slow down) slightly to do so.
Ivan Jourdain (an otherwise perfect example of a better breed of human being) could not slide, leading to some very comical collisions similar to what would happen if the Hulk jogged into Spider Man.
-#10 on the pennant leaderboard.
Post a Comment